1. Message and relevance — 10 points

  • The first screen names the audience or situation.
  • The primary outcome is understandable without scrolling.
  • The offer is specific enough to reject poor-fit visitors.
  • The main heading uses customer language rather than internal jargon.
  • The supporting text explains why the visitor should continue.
  • Location or service area is visible when it affects eligibility.
  • Urgent and non-urgent visitors have different next steps when needed.
  • The page matches the ad, keyword or link that brought the visitor.
  • One action is visually primary.
  • The mobile first screen preserves the same message.

2. Proof and risk reduction — 8 points

  • Proof appears before or beside a major decision.
  • Reviews include a source or verifiable context.
  • Case studies separate facts from projections or concept work.
  • Licenses, guarantees and certifications are accurate and current.
  • The process explains what happens after the inquiry.
  • Real contact details and an accountable company identity are visible.
  • Privacy and data-use expectations are linked near forms.
  • Claims avoid unsupported superlatives and invented performance numbers.

3. Action and friction — 8 points

  • The CTA describes the next step, not merely “Submit.”
  • The commitment requested matches the visitor’s readiness.
  • The form asks only for information used in qualification or response.
  • Errors explain how to fix the field.
  • Success state confirms delivery and response expectations.
  • Phone numbers, email links and booking controls work on mobile.
  • The visitor can recover if the form or booking tool fails.
  • The business tests the form after every meaningful release.

4. Measurement and follow-up — 7 points

  • Analytics records successful submissions, not button clicks alone.
  • Campaign and source data reach the lead record.
  • Booking, contact and scan requests are separate events.
  • Duplicate and spam submissions are identifiable.
  • Delivery to email or CRM is monitored.
  • Response time and qualification outcome are measured.
  • Sales can report which sources produce customers.

5. Technical confidence — 7 points

  • The page has one descriptive H1 and a useful title.
  • Canonical, sitemap and indexation rules point to the intended URL.
  • The page is usable by keyboard and form controls have names.
  • Meaningful images have appropriate alternative text.
  • The mobile layout avoids horizontal overflow and tiny targets.
  • The initial experience remains useful on a slower connection.
  • Broken links, redirect chains and console errors are checked.

How to use the score.

Score one point for each item that is demonstrably true. A score is not a conversion guarantee; it is a way to make an ambiguous review repeatable. Fix failed items in this order: traffic-message match, conversion-path failures, trust gaps, follow-up gaps and then incremental polish.

Run the checklist on one high-intent landing page, not on the average of the entire website. Recheck it after changes and pair it with qualified-lead data.

ScoreInterpretationNext move
34–40Strong foundationTest message and offer variants
26–33Visible leaksFix the first failed stage in the journey
18–25Material frictionPrioritize conversion and trust sprint
0–17Unclear or broken pathRebuild the core journey before buying more traffic